Let us delve into the fascinating world of Cognitive Constellation Corps and this incredible nine-track composition, “Thank You for Your Feedback (I)”. Understanding that this particular piece is the creative brainchild of artist Brooke Tamsin Clevenger of Belfast provides us with such an immense amount of depth with regard to this music. Given that Brooke has been working with electronics since the mid-1990s, the relationship she holds with technology goes far beyond just using it as a tool; she views it as an interactive and responsive creation partner. And that is the reason why “Thank You for Your Feedback (I)” is so immaculately crafted. With such an extensive discography of more than hundreds of songs and such an extensive fan base of over half a million plays on SoundCloud, this album is the perfect culmination of Brooke’s development as an artist. She puts into use her lifelong interest in the subject of consciousness, identity, memory, and human experience philosophy to create a nine-track album. The reason why “Thank You for Your Feedback (I)” is so successful is the seamless way that it juxtaposes the coldness of digital architecture with warmth and bleeding-heart vulnerability. In the process of turning the clinical jargon of machine learning feedback into an exploration of human relationships, Brooke proves that she is an absolute genius when it comes to concept and execution alike. Each song seamlessly blends into the next one in a completely unprecedented way, creating the effect of being transported into a whole new world. Being able to see this kind of artist in action is a true blessing.
The album trip starts with a song that creates an atmosphere and sets the stage. “Opening Loop (i)” is a song that is not introduced by a strong beat or catchy vocals but by a slow-developing atmospheric sound of synthesizers that gives the impression of being in a digital dream state. The slow-developing sounds create a feeling of calm and expectation rather than overt tones. In terms of lyrics and concept, the song introduces the main theme of the album, which is a cycle of communication and self-analysis created by modern people who try to understand each other’s signals. The character in the song is trying to reach out to someone, and somehow someone hears her and tells him that she didn’t intend for him to hear her; however, she’s the loop that he heard and knows. From a musical standpoint, the song makes use of an elegant interplay between warm and dreamy analog pads and sparse and trance-like electronic beats that evoke the ticking of a clock or circuitry running on repeat. No lead vocals are present, which allows the sonic artistry of the music to carry itself. Its effect on the listener is very grounding, bringing you inside yourself while stripping away external distractions before the emotional journey to come.
Following well with the atmosphere created by the former piece, “Signal Received (i)” opens up with a sharp and bubbly rhythm of crisp electronic beats intertwined with a slowly rising atmospheric buzz, creating an impression of a signal traveling across a long digital expanse to reach its destination. Literally, the song can mean a user receiving a signal, but, Metaphorically, this song touches on the concept of anxiety and vulnerability of sending a message over emotional distances and the uncertainty that arises about whether the intended recipients receive our messages and expressions in the right manner. The character in the song thanks the person who has heard him or her, saying thank you because he didn’t expect a reply; he just put himself or herself out there and finds someone who makes a tune with him or her. Where tune here refers to a relationship. As far as the music is concerned, the vocals here have a breathy feel, are intimate in their nature, and are accompanied by a subtle harmony of sounds that hover around an animated layer of synth pop beats and rhythmic electronic sounds. The music here combines the warmth of natural elements along with sleek electronic beats. For the listener, this song will give you a shot of silent adrenaline, making you feel nervous to wait for someone’s response that might change your life forever.
Venturing further into the emotional heart of the project, the song “Thank You For Your Feedback (i)” opens with a delicate piano melody that is accompanied by a soft rhythmic ticking sound, which seems oddly intimate. The main theme of the song revolves around the harsh experience of living in an age where constant evaluation and criticism have become the norm and a common phenomenon within corporate life. Like the previous songs on this album, this song can be seen as simply thanking someone for their feedback, on its surface level, but, metaphorically, the lyrics tell the story of struggling to remake oneself to be accepted and understood by others, until one reaches a point where he realizes that criticism is just a form of control over him and not communication. The situation that this character faces is not uncommon. Many of us have allowed ourselves to be remodeled and reconditioned to be a certain way or like a certain thing to make the person that we love comfortable and happy. Some people see this sacrifice and love us deeply and care for us, while some weaponize it and end up breaking us in the process. From a musical perspective, the vocal performance is soft, natural, and emotionally charged, with a slow tempo and dream pop production keeping things simple in such a way that each word hits hard. The effect it has on the listener is amazing, as it feels like a calming exhale, giving validation to the human desire to be authentic amidst all those opinions.
Exploring deeper into the psychological structure of the album, “Echo Chamber (i)” opens with an abrupt reverberated vocal loop that ricochets back and forth between the left and right channels, quickly creating the sensation of feeling trapped in a continuous cycle of recurring thoughts. The concept centers around themes of isolation, confirmation bias, and how we can become more fearful and insecure by turning inward on ourselves rather than continuing to interact in the world at large. Like the other songs on this album, this song seems like it’s about echoing room, but it has a deeper meaning. The Lyrics explore the feeling of being isolated within the digital spaces of today, where opposing viewpoints are blocked from us, and all that remains is an echo of our own voice. Musicality-wise, the vocals are eerie and multi-layered, thus giving off the effect of an ethereal chorus, enveloping the listener, whereas the instrumental part includes spinning, entrancing synthesizers along with the pulsating beat of electronic heartbeats which recreate the effect of a light panic attack. The result is highly atmospheric and slightly disconcerting and compels the listener to do some introspection of themselves.
Conveying the feeling of illumination and breakthrough, “The Curve of Clarity (i)” begins with a flow of shimmering synthesizer sounds that seem like the first beams of sunshine penetrating through the dense layer of fog in the early morning. The idea of the song revolves around the breakthrough, that moment of insight when you can understand something clearly and honestly without any doubts. It is a rare and liberating instant when one gets a clear vision about his relationship, situation, and himself. In the realm of music, the track boasts an airy synth sound, great rhythm section work, and a superb vocal delivery that sounds very refreshing and free. The instruments are rich yet minimalistic, providing enough space for the vocal lines. Listening to the track, one gets an incredible sense of relief and hope; it’s like taking a deep breath after a lot of thinking in the previous songs.
The tone shifts to one that is rather coarse, as the song “Threadbare, Threadshare (i)” begins with a thin sound, produced using plucking of acoustic or synthesized strings along with a subtle noise, reminiscent of the noise that can be heard from thinning material due to constant stress applied to it. This track revolves around the idea of exhaustion, where you keep on giving away parts of yourself until you no longer have anything left and then exposing your weak sides to the whole world that does not appreciate it at all. The vocals in terms of music theory are weak, emotional, and trembling in their purity and rawness against the simple background of sorrowful electronic sounds and ambient drones. It affects the listeners in a very emotional way – it touches the strings of everyone who experienced being overstretched while trying to take care of others or fulfill some unrealistic demands.
With its energetic pace characterized by an intense, driving rhythm, the song “The Response Loop (You’re Still Talking)” opens up with a catchy drum-machine beat and bass line that creates a sense of nostalgia for the 80s with a contemporary twist. The concept is focused on the irritating situation of one-sided discussions, unsolicited advice, and individuals who just won’t shut up due to their tendency to hear themselves talk. The lyrics are funny and perceptive in their commentary on the incessant noise surrounding communication. In terms of music, the voice is brassy, bold, and dripping in cool detachment and irony, which fits the vibrant and danceable music. The effect is refreshingly wild and invigorating; it transforms one’s irritation into something one can dance to, providing a release for one’s irritation at all those interpersonal interactions.
Moving slightly into darker territory, “Harmonic Distortion (i)” opens with a deep, growling bass drone that slowly shatters into a fuzzy electronic wave, representing the idea of a signal being pushed to the point where it disintegrates. This song centers around the ideas of emotional tension, miscommunication, and the distortion of meaning through misinterpretation. This track delves into the problem of misunderstandings that occur due to interference and distortion of intentions in modern conversations. From the standpoint of music, “Harmonic Distortion (i)” has highly processed vocals that make it difficult to distinguish between a natural human voice and digital processing. The song has a gloomy industrial-sounding electronic composition with harsh electronic waves. The result is extremely intense and captivating for the listener.
Concluding the entire conceptual journey with a stunning finale, “Always (i) [Sevahem]” starts with an inviting and enveloping ambience of chords that seem ancient yet futuristic simultaneously, gradually giving way to a peaceful heartbeat-like rhythm. The track rises above the worries about the digital age and the interpersonal relations expressed in the previous tracks, moving on to a profound meditation on true, eternal love, spiritual constancy, and those things that are still constant in our lives after the buzz of feedback and appraisal is gone. The lyrics present a timeless commitment to devotion and peace within oneself. In musical terms, the track delivers the most beautiful vocals imaginable, full of grace, angelic harmonies, and emotional purity that unites the warmth of classical atmosphere with the progress of electronic music.
“Thank You for Your Feedback (I)” is an extraordinary, peerless piece of evidence of such high artistry. An artist transforms the familiar phrase that most of us have become used to hearing, a cold, algorithmic piece of procedural language produced by machine-like mechanisms, into something unique and intimate, ambiguous, and highly human. “Thank You for Your Feedback (I)” floats easily through a beautiful array of indie pop, dream pop, and laidback electronic music, with a leisurely and hypnotizing rhythm, whispering vocals, and a soothing electronic production that envelops you like a cocoon. It is absolutely mesmerizing to see how this artist manages to convey the stiff and lifeless language of binary digits into something raw, tremulous, and colorful, reflecting the complexity of the feelings and relations of humans. The unity of themes and sounds in this entire ride is unparalleled; there is not even a single track that does not merge effortlessly with the next one, creating an entire universe which looks fully developed and alive. To have been able to follow this artistic soul through all these years has been a great honor, and it fills me with pride to watch how he elevates his art to such amazing heights. Thundering congratulations to the one who created a classic in just a moment; I can already count the excruciating minutes before the next release!
Stream the “Thank You for Your Feedback (I)” album on Spotify.
Follow Cognitive Constellation Corps here and their socials: Facebook, Instagram, Bandcamp, YouTube
